What a Pirate Chick Taught Me About AI and Marketing
The other day, my 6-year-old and I were doing a little art project together when he gave me a very specific request: “Dad, we need a picture of a baby chick dressed as a pirate.”
“Yeah, sure,” I responded, no questions asked. “Let me whip that up for you.”
30 seconds later, I had this to share with him:

“That’s perfect, thanks!”
Was the skull-and-crossbones image a little off? Sure.
Would the chick have commanded more piratey vibes had it been wearing an eye patch? You bet, but I deserve the blame there for not mentioning that in my prompt.
That’s when that little Pirate Chick taught me a valuable lesson: AI makes is easy, but it doesn’t necessarily make it great.
AI has lowered the entry barrier for so many creative services, from illustration to script writing to animation and motion design – the list goes on and on. As a marketer on the agency side, the rise of AI capabilities initially felt threatening, but after rolling up my sleeves and digging in, I’ll be the first to admit that I love what AI is doing for the industry.
Mostly, that is.
On the one hand, it’s making our output better, faster, and more efficient. Giving folks a marketing toolkit with a far greater breadth than ever before = amazing.
Lowering the creative barrier to entry to the point where AI slop dominates online video placements and social media threads = worse than the supposed skull-and-crossbones adorning that little pirate chick’s headband.
So yes, AI is making it easier than ever to crank out marketing materials at record speed. But easier doesn’t automatically mean better, and it doesn’t mean you can skip the fundamentals.
Just because there’s a 10-minute YouTube tutorial on rewiring a circuit board doesn’t mean you should grab a screwdriver and start poking around. The same logic applies here.
Before diving headfirst into production, there are some critical things to get right. Who are you talking to? What are you trying to achieve? What’s the message? Where is it going to live? Skip those steps and your campaign might look polished on the surface, but underneath it’ll feel disjointed, forgettable, or worse: completely off-target.
Then there’s the AI question itself.
Not every piece of content benefits from looking like it was generated in 30 seconds, because, well, sometimes it shows. When your goal is to build trust, credibility, or an emotional connection, that “AI sheen” can work against you. If the audience instantly clocks it as synthetic, you’re asking them to emotionally invest in something that already feels a little… disposable.
That doesn’t mean avoid AI. It just means use it with intention, because the difference between “this is amazing” and “this is AI slop” isn’t the tool – it’s the thinking behind it.
